I Knew It!
I always wondered about this and Some Study That The Economist Found Credible Enough To Write About agrees: Index funds are bad. It's almost beyond debate that, for an investor, index funds are better than actively managed funds. But for the broader economy, that may not be true. It's because they blunt the process of investors making informed decisions about the relative prices and strengths of sectors and companies. People are going to keep buying Nvidia and Palantir as long as they are in the index, no matter how crazy high their PE ratios get (Nvidia: around 49, not that crazy; Palantir: around 400, beyond crazy; boring old Royal Bank: 17). The hope was that arbitrageurs would force prices back into line, but this study finds that their effect is very small compared to the mass of hundreds of millions of people plowing money into the S&P index automatically, month after month. Interesting!